Sadly, the screen’s first James Bond, Sean Connery, has passed away at the age of 90. In his honor, I’ve written a post about one of his lesser known films — The Anderson Tapes.
Directed by the consummate Sidney Lumet and co-starring Dyan Cannon, Martin Balsam, Alan King, and a young Christopher Walken, The Anderson Tapes is a quirky heist movie, which also takes a critical look at the pervasive use of surveillance in modern society. Whether it’s government wire taps, residential security cameras, prison monitors, or bank ID photos, the film lets us know that someone is constantly keeping tabs on us.
Although a commendable attempt at exposing the moral ambiguity of prolific monitoring technologies in the 1970s, it does feel a bit dated today. I believe that if Lumet pushed the surveillance theme to the absurd levels as he did in his 1976 film, Network, this film might’ve retained a more timeless quality. I also think Quincy Jones’ futuristic electronic soundtrack was somewhat distracting, invariably reminding you that you’re watching a 1971 film that’s trying to be hipper beyond its decade. However, the film does have its charms. Almost all the leading actors give well-developed, engaging performances, and I’m always a sucker for a good heist story. Plus, Lumet being Lumet, he offers us a slew of interesting NYC locations.
Arriving from Prison
It was already established on several websites that this scene was shot in the Port Authority Bus Terminal on 8th Avenue. But since the images in the film didn’t resemble what the bus station looks like today, I was in search of any vintage photos to confirm it was the same place.
After a little digging around, I stumbled upon a few black & white photographs from the late 1960s, showing what PABT looked like before it got remodeled in 1979. Amazingly, the station was much more charming in appearance, looking more like a small airport than a bus terminal.
After finding those black & white images, not only was I certain they filmed inside PABT, but I now had a better idea where the scene on the mezzanine took place. However, I was never able to find any information or vintage photos of where they shot the very end of this sequence, which featured several futuristic-looking seating stations. For more information about Port Authority Bus Terminal, see my article on Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950), where I look at the history of an array of bus terminals in NYC.
Prior to this sequence at PABT, the movie begins with Duke Anderson and his fellow inmates being processed and released from prison. Several modern sources indicated they shot these scenes on Rikers Island, but I was very cautious to blindly assume that they actually filmed there. This caution came from my experiences doing research for this “NYC in Film” project. Over the years, I have encountered instances when one person cites an incorrect filming location (usually on IMDB or Wikipedia) and then several other movie websites would promulgate this error, giving the impression that the purported filming location was backed up with multiple sources. So, the last thing I wanted to do was repeat this malfeasance on this website.
But I had high hopes that the information for this scene was correct. I figured if it was explicitly indicated in the screen story that these characters were leaving Rikers Island, someone might’ve simply cited Rikers as a filming location on a website without doing any research. But since the characters were being released from an unnamed prison, I assumed there must be some reliable sources out there that were the basis for this filming location assertion. However, after my initial research into the subject, I couldn’t find anything outside of movie websites that indicated that Lumet used the New York facility. I later found a 2016 article in the Queens Gazette that said The Anderson Tapes was filmed there, but the author could have gotten her information from a modern (and potentially unreliable) source like IMDB.
Finally, I was able to track down one contemporaneous source that referred to the production being on Rikers Island — a syndicated news article by Earl Wilson which was circulated in late-September/early-October of 1970.
“This city’s bad!” Sean Connery said. Speaking, of course, of Fun City. “But it’s the most colorful in the world. In my hotel a woman threw a bag on the elevator right at the door so the lift couldn’t go down, then she ran back inside. I waited, then I went in to say, ‘Hey!’ She was packing another bag.
“I was walking down the street with Marty Balsam when a man came up and shouted an anti-Semitic remark at me. I said ‘ME?’ Marty told the fellow. ‘Not him! ME!.’
I was trying to get breakfast in a little restaurant when a woman who bad two sets of eyebrows painted on her eyebrows screamed at me. ‘YOU CAN’T ORDER AHEAD OF ME. I WAS HERE FIRST!'”
Connery, who’s here filming “The Anderson Tapes,” shooting scenes in Rikers Island Prison among other places, says he got into the mood and put on a holdup man’s mask walking the street. “And nobody noticed anything strange!”
I kind of doubt all of those wild Connery stories are true, but one unexpected thing that caught my attention in that article was a reference to “Fun City” — which turns out was a short-lived moniker for NYC in the 1960s and 1970s. Apparently, it was based on a statement made in 1966 by the city’s newly-elected mayor, John Lindsay, who was facing a debilitating transit-strike, but declared, “I still think it’s a fun city,.”
His upbeat, but rather ineffective outlook in the face of the city’s mounting problems —the garbage and teachers’ strikes, prison riots, soaring poverty and crime— was met with mockery by cynical Gothamites.
New York Herald Tribune writer, Dick Schaap, was the first to coin the phrase, satirizing the mayor’s “fun city” quote in his metro column, making the point that a lighthearted attitude won’t solve the city’s dire situation.
”I grabbed the words, capitalized them and ran with them,” he later wrote.
For the next couple of years, the sardonic nickname was embraced by many New Yorkers, regularly appearing in news articles, advertisements, and Times Square porno shops. It even became the title of a Joan Rivers play that briefly ran on Broadway in 1972, and was the name of one of tracks for John Barry’s soundtrack for the 1969 film, Midnight Cowboy.
Since then, the moniker has basically disappeared from the New York lexicon. However, there was a brief reference to it during Michael Bloomberg’s tenure as mayor when critics of his bans on smoking and oversized sugar drinks began referring to New York as “No-Fun City.”
Even though the reference to Rikers Island in that 1970 news article was only in passing, it was enough to make me fairly confident that the movie was indeed shot there. But I still wanted to find some pictorial evidence to give me full satisfaction. I watched several harrowing documentaries about the long-established institution, but I couldn’t find any images that matched any of the shots from the film. Finally, after sifting through endless pictures of Rikers Island (most of which were of the outside), I found a couple shots of the inside from the 1930s and 1950s that appeared to show some matching details.
After discovering those vintage photos, I became confident that production filmed on Rikers Island, and believed they most likely used a cellblock inside Rikers House of Detention for Men (HDM). Constructed in 1933, the 1,200-bed, maximum security complex was the island’s first permanent jail, and was renamed James A. Thomas Center in 1989 to honor the DOC’s first African-American warden (which is ironic since, according to reporter Sylvia Kronstadt, Thomas thought it was a “barbaric facility”). Still-standing, the three-story structure is no longer used to house inmates (although this past summer, its rooftop was used as an escape route for a fleeing prisoner).
Banking and Shopping
Finding the location of the store was a fairly simple task since the name “Korvettes Fifth Avenue” appears on a sign in the background. After a little research I was able to figure out that the store’s official address was 575 Fifth Avenue.
But before Korvettes opened this location on Fifth Avenue, it had spent the previous 14 years pioneering a new frontier in discount retailing, reinventing the “five-and-dime store” model. Starting in 1948 with a small shop that sold luggage out of a Manhattan loft space, Korvettes had expanded to dozens of department store locations throughout the New York metropolitan area by the late 1950s, offering prices 10 to 40 percent below competing stores. Korvettes’ success had a lot do with an innovative strategy of establishing itself as a co-op entity through the distribution of “membership cards” to all of its customers. By doing that, they were able to undercut suggested retail prices on expensive items without violating anti-discounting provisions of the Robinson-Patman Act.
In May of 1962, during its height of popularity, Korvettes opened the giant, 8-story department store featured in this film on the southeast corner of 47th Street and Fifth Avenue. In the lead-up to its grand opening, Korvettes was apparently the source of much consternation among its neighbors. The concern was that the opening of a “discount store” could tarnish the reputation of the area’s luxury retailers, such as Bergdorf Goodman, Lord & Taylor, and Saks Fifth Avenue. 
However, Korvettes ended up fitting into the ritzy shopping area quite well. The newly-renovated interior of the store was more elegant than the usual “bare-bones” aesthetics found in their other outlets, and management made sure their stock included a wide variety of upscale items. According to an article in the New York Times, opening day customers saw an assortment of merchandise that ranged from 88¢ costume jewelry to a $15,000 diamond neckless.
The flagship store did well for several years, becoming something of a tourist attraction, similar to Macy’s at Herald Square. But after Korvettes’ founder Eugene Ferkauf sold his share of the company in 1966, the chainstore’s merchandising image started becoming muddled.
By the mid-1970s, business started dwindling, and in 1980, the store filed for bankruptcy. Shortly after that, the new owners of the Fifth Avenue property prepared to convert the building into a combination retail/office space, hoping to revitalize the neighborhood whose luster had faded over the last decade. But rather than tearing down the old building, developers built around the former store’s 8-story steel structure, and added a 27-story tower on top of that, which was slightly inset from the original “footprint.”
Completed in the fall of 1983, the pink-granite structure that sits on that corner today no longer resembles the Korvettes building whose innards are technically still part of the architecture.
Even though I call it the “Korvettes building,” when it was originally constructed in 1912, it was for a high-end carpet and furniture company called W&J Sloane. Before that, the block was home to the Windsor Arcade, which was a 3-story, Beaux Arts shopping center that is thought by some to be an early prototype of the modern mall.
Before the arcade was erected in 1901, the corner lot was home to the Hotel Windsor (which ended ed up being destroyed in a tragic fire). Before the hotel was established in 1873, most of Fifth Avenue above 42nd Street was basically a rural setting. In fact, the entire block between 46th and 47th Streets used to be a cow pasture, originally sold to a pair of brothers for a total sum of about $2,000.
While figuring out the location of the department store was fairly easy, figuring out the location of the bank was a little more challenging, mostly because the scene didn’t contain any clearly visible signage. But by the looks of the interior, I guessed that it was most likely in the Midtown East area, as the banks there tended to have the same bland, but spacious design seen in the film.
Even though there weren’t too many details in the buildings outside the bank windows, I was still hopeful that they’d offer a clue to this location. After studying the scene, my ever-adroit research partner, Jeff Blakeslee, thought he recognized the blue building with the red lettering. He had a feeling the building was located on 42nd Street somewhere, and after a quick trip to Google Street View, he confirmed it was on the southwest corner of E 42nd Street and Third Avenue. (Turns out there used to be a Woolworth’s store on the ground floor, which accounted for the red lettering that appeared in the film.) From there, we concluded they filmed this bank scene in the building katy-corner to it.
Aside from the red Woolworth signage, the blue building looks the same today as it did in 1970. However, the building that’s across the street at 666 Third Avenue looks significantly different, despite having a construction date of 1952. It appears as though when real estate developers, Tishman Speyer Properties, acquired the neighboring Chrysler Building in the late 1990s, they also took possession of the less-glamorous 666 Third Avenue with the intention of turning the entire square block into a “Chrysler Center.” In this $100 million project, it was decided to add 130,000 square feet to the Third Avenue building (now called Chrysler East) and clad it with a new metal and glass facade, thus altering its appearance to what it looks like today.
It might be noted that for the bank’s “before/after” image at the top of this section, the modern view was taken on the street, opposed to inside the Bank of America, which currently occupies the space. I’ve found that financial institutions can be a bit touchy when you start snapping pictures on their premises. Maybe some day, I can sneak a frame or two while inside the bank, but until then, the street pic (which shows the same general relation to the other buildings) will have to do.
The Apartment Building
This lavish apartment block was identified on many websites to be located at 1 East 91st Street on the corner of Fifth Avenue. And since the exterior of the building has changed very little over the years, it was fairly easy to make the match.
Made up of two former private mansions, the space has been home to the Convent of the Sacred Heart —an independent Roman Catholic all-girls school— since the 1930s. This landmarked Italianate palazzo overlooks Central Park, and is also across the street from the Cooper Hewitt Smithsonian Design Museum, which has appeared in numerous films, including Jumping’ Jack Flash, Arthur, and Marathon Man. Most of the interiors were reportedly filmed on studio sets, but production did end up filming a few bits inside the actual Catholic school, showcasing its striking interior design (see “the Robbery” scene below).
I’m not quite sure where the rest of these interiors were filmed, as there doesn’t seem to be a consensus out there. TCM claims interiors were shot at Hi Brown Studio and ABC-Path Studio in New York, while IMDB says they were done at New York Production Center Studios at 221 West 26th Street. I have yet to find a reliable source to confirm whether production used any of these places.
Mob Restaurant
I thought finding the location to this restaurant scene, like most interior scenes, would be a difficult task. But the scene was clearly taking place in an Italian eatery which had a uniquely characteristic decor, so I thought it was certainly possible to identify.
Fortunately, Bob Egan’s historical website, PopSpotsNYC, which finds New York locations of notable album covers and other pop cultural events, had an article that turned out to be very helpful. In it, Egan talked about tracking down the location of a photo on the back cover of Billy Joel’s 1977 LP, The Stranger, which he concluded was inside Guido’s Supreme Macaroni Pasta Company on Ninth Avenue.
Even though his main focus was on Joel’s album, the article also mentioned a few movies that were shot inside the restaurant, including The Anderson Tapes. The Supreme Macaroni Company was also used in Woody Allen’s Mighty Aphrodite, the Michael J. Fox drama Bright Lights, Big City, and perhaps most famously, Léon: The Professional, starring a young Natalie Portman.
On Egan’s website,Tarra Tournour (nee Scarola), whose father owned the Italian eatery, wrote in and gave some details about the restaurant and its famed history:
The Supreme Macaroni Co. was started in 1947 by my great-grandmother Asunta (Susie) Scarola and her second husband (my step great-grandfather) Guido. The building was a pasta factory called the Supreme Macaroni Co. when they purchased it and they simply kept the name. Susie and Guido started with a deli and Guido would occasionally cook in the back.
One thing that struck me was Tarra’s account of the restaurant name. She said that the family just adopted the name left behind by the previous occupants, but when I looked at the 1939-1941 tax records of the address, the business was called, “Insuperable Macaroni Company”. I couldn’t a listing for “Insuperable” or “Supreme” in a 1946 phonebook, so I’m not sure what the whole story is.
Anyway, after listing the movies shot in her family’s restaurant, Tarra described other connections they had with the entertainment world:
Several commercials and magazine photo shoots featured the restaurant and it was mentioned in Nevada Barr’s novel “Liberty Falling” because she was a fan. Even 10 years after it closed, the author Adrianna Trigiani named her latest novel “The Supreme Macaroni Co.” because she ate dinner there many times and liked the name.
Finally, many stars dined at the restaurant – Rob Reiner, Alec Baldwin, John F. Kennedy Jr., Ava Gardner, Carol Burnett, Frank Sinatra, Ingrid Bergman, Mickey Rooney, Brooke Shields, The Police, Peter, Paul and Mary, The Who, Rudy Guiliani, Ed MacMahon, and John Ritter just to name a few.
Sadly, like many other cultural places with rich New York history, the restaurant (along with half the block) got torn down around 2009 to make way for luxury apartments and a boutique hotel.
Even though I never went inside the Supreme Macaroni Co, I do remember passing it several times in the 1990’s, back when that section of Hell’s Kitchen was still a vibrant ethnic neighborhood. There are still a few traditional mom-and-pop shops along Ninth Avenue, but they’re slowly disappearing, and at some point, all we’ll have left is album covers and old movies to remind us of what that area used to be like.
Agents Seek Surveillance Warrant
I could tell this scene was shot in a real courthouse —opposed to a set— by the looks of the room’s battered fixtures, and more importantly, by the skyline seen out the window. In fact, it was those buildings seen out the window that helped me pinpoint this location.
I guessed that Lumet filmed this scene in one of the courthouses in downtown Manhattan, so I just looked around the area until I found the pair of skyscrapers that matched the ones that appeared behind the judge. I determined the older, classic Beaux-Arts building on the left was 15 Park Row (est. 1896, and former home to J&R Music World) and the more modern-looking building next to it was 222 Broadway (est. 1961). The skyline was still looking a little open back then because this was a couple years before the completion of the 743-foot One Liberty Plaza, which was built for Merrill Lynch (and included such amenities as a sauna for their executives on the 50th floor).
Taking into account the vantage point of those skyscrapers, I estimated that production either used the Tweed Courthouse or the Surrogate’s Court — both located on Chambers Street, just north of City Hall. After considering the window’s close proximity to trees, I started leaning more towards Tweed, which is situated inside City Hall Park. Then, after a little digging around, I found a couple photos taken inside a courtroom, showing the windows and doors, which matched the film perfectly.
Tweed Courthouse is located on the north side of City Hall Park on Chambers Street and is supposedly New York City’s second permanent government building, following the adjacent City Hall (est. 1811). Starting in 1861, the marble courthouse took 20 years to build, delayed by the Civil War and a shake-up in “Boss” Tweed’s political group (who allegedly used the construction as way to facilitate an embezzling scheme). By the time the courthouse opened in 1881, William “Boss” Tweed had already died in jail after being convicted on charges of forgery and grand larceny. It is estimated that the building ended up costing taxpayers around $250 million (adjusted for inflation), most of which ended up in the pockets of corrupt political leaders.
Tweed Courthouse has been a landmarked building since 1984, but its destruction had been an ardent mission of civic leaders for most of the 20th century, probably because the building’s been so closely associated with the sordid crimes of “Boss” Tweed and his bloated construction costs. Ironically, the only thing that saved this courthouse from being razed in 1975 was a NYC fiscal crisis that made it impossible for the city to afford demolition costs, let alone the cost of building a replacement.
By the mid-1970s, Tweed had ceased to be used as a working courthouse, and less than 10% of the building’s space was being used at all. In 1979, NYC’s Municipal Archives was temporarily relocated there for four years, until they could move into their permanent space at the Surrogate’s Court. Blakeslee found a remarkable government website which republished a 1983 article written for the archive department’s newsletter that described what it was like working in a “beautiful but imperfect building.” The article also gave a brief history of the courthouse, including the various movies that were shot there, and shared several rare photographs taken during the department’s four-year sojourn.
Because the building was more or less lying dormant by the 1970s, it became the perfect shooting location for moviemakers seeking out an authentic-looking courthouse. One of the first productions that filmed inside the space was the Academy-Award winning film, Kramer vs. Kramer, which used one of the courtrooms on the third floor for its climactic custody-battle scenes. Shortly after that, in 1979, director Brian DePalma transformed the building into a police station and an insane asylum for his thriller, Dressed to Kill, starring Michael Caine, Angie Dickinson, and the always-gruff Dennis Franz.
According to the 1983 newsletter, director Sidney Lumet used the courthouse for two of his films, Prince of the City, and The Verdict, even though the latter was supposed to be taking place in Boston. In order to achieve an “old Boston” look, production gave the Courthouse an extensive makeover, which included adding fake statues, marbleizing the plaster pillars, and painting the hallways chocolate, cream and gold. Apparently, the city liked production’s makeover and didn’t require them to restore the courthouse to its original “dingy beige” color scheme afterwards. (Although I can only assume the fake statues were removed.)
I noticed that the Archival Society’s newsletter didn’t make mention of The Anderson Tapes, but I figured it was most likely because it was shot years before the department moved into the space and they didn’t have a firsthand account of the production. Regardless, I’m almost 100% positive that The Anderson Tapes was shot in Tweed Courthouse.
Unfortunately, even though public tours have been made available, I haven’t yet had a chance to see the inside of the building (which got a massive renovation in the 1990s before becoming the headquarters for the Department of Education). But considering the state of things right now, it seems unlikely I will have access to the old courthouse any time soon, so that cruddy Google Maps image of the outlying skyline will have to serve as the “modern pic” for my “before/after” image for now.
Electronic Store
I simply used the surplus store’s name and number to track down this filming location, since I thought the storefront in the scene looked authentic. Using the full name in a Google search, I found a 1963 article in American Modeler magazine written by “Battling Bob” Hatschek that mentions the New York shop and gives a full address of 332 Canal Street. I then found several other online sources giving the same street number, confirming the location and saving me a trip to the public library and having to look up the store’s name in an old Manhattan phonebook. 
For the longest time, the retail space at no. 332 was home to a cheap electronic store, which was typical for Canal Street. But around 2015, things started changing in the area, and most of the bargain stores shut down and were replaced with high-end shops and boutiques. But you can see by the “before/after” image above, that a lot of the commercial spaces are still unoccupied (most likely due to intimidatingly high rents).
Black Panthers
Jeff Blakeslee was the one who found this location. The most obvious clue he worked from was the yellow and red theater that had a marquee with a gigantic 62 on it. Assuming that the number was the building address, a Google search for “new york theater” plus “62 east” got him a couple hits for a theater located at 62 East Fourth Street, which was called the Channel One Theatre in 1971.
After consulting the 1940 tax records and checking out the address in Google Street View, Blakeslee and I concluded that we got the correct location. Even though the Black Panthers building has changed dramatically since the 1970s, its two neighboring buildings currently look about the same, and number 62 is even still a theater.
Dating back to 1890 for a cost of around $35,000, the building at 62 E 4th Street was originally conceived as a restaurant and lodging house by German immigrant, Victor Eckstein. The design included private quarters on the top floor for his 8-member family, along with a unique circular fire escape that ran down the front of the building, camouflaged by a perforated iron mesh.
Eckstein’s restaurant operated out of the ground floor and basement for several years, but the building has basically served as a theater and meeting hall for most of its existence. Over the years, 62 E 4th Street has had a variety of different names, such as Astoria Hall, the Royal Playhouse, the Rodale Theater, the New York Theater Ensemble, and the Fortune Theatre (at which time Andy Warhol and his associate, Gerard Malangato, rented out the second floor to put on a series of male porno films). When The Anderson Tapes was filmed in the summer of 1970, the space was known as the Channel One Theatre. (You can see the name on the side of the marquee in the scene.)
Co-founded by Ken Shapiro and Lane Sarasohn in 1967, the Channel One Theatre showcased satirical “underground television” productions which involved videotaped skits being “broadcast” on three B&W television monitors hung from the theater ceiling. Along with Shapiro, the cast included actor/comedian Richard Belzer and a pre-SNL Chevy Chase. A few years later, the best skits from their shows would be compiled together to form a 1974 film called, The Groove Tube, which some say helped pave the way for shows like SNL and SCTV.
Since the early 2000’s, this part of the East Village has experienced a revitalization of the theater scene, with a bunch of small venues lining both sides of East 4th Street between 2nd Avenue and Bowery. And as far as I can tell, 62 E 4th still houses a theater (along with a dance company and a karate studio).
As to the apartment used by the surveillance team in this scene, I estimate that it was located on the second floor of 71 E 4th Street, across the street from the Black Panthers building. If looking at no. 71 from the street, the actors would have been looking out the third window from the right.
Pop Calls Duke
By the looks of the background, I assumed that this brief scene was shot in Times Square — it was just a matter of figuring out the exact block. The biggest clue was the Ripley’s Wax Museum seen behind the phone. After doing a general internet search, I was surprised by how little information there was about the popular tourist attraction, which was in the Square for nearly a quarter of a century. I was also surprised I couldn’t find one picture of Ripley’s when I did a Google image search.
I eventually found a New York Times article written on January 9th, 1972, that described the museum and its closure. According to the article, Ripley’s Wax Museum, which featured historical and cultural statues, as well as reproductions of torture devices and other grim oddities, had been a New York institution since 1948. However, due to diminishing receipts and a general decline in NYC tourism, Ripley’s executive vice president, Charles Bristol, decided to close down the wax museum at the end of 1971. The executive, who described Broadway as the “Avenue of Perverts,” told the Times that “Times Square used to be the best tourist area of the world. But it’s gone downhill severely. Now most people stay away from it.”
However, some critics thought the museum’s decline in popularity had more to do with its inability to update its exhibits to reflect the changing times. Also, a pair of suspicious fires in February and May of 1971 (one of which killed an AWOL sailor) certainly didn’t help the tourist attraction’s prospects of staying open.
In addition to the details of its closure, the Times article provided the exact address of Ripley’s Wax Museum, which was 1539 Broadway, placing it on the west side of Times Square between 45th and 46th Streets. (Although the newspaper erroneously described it as being between 43rd and 44th.)
After getting an exact address, I decided to adopt a new strategy in my search for a picture of Ripley’s, focusing my attention on a pair of movie theaters (the Astor and the Victoria) that were situated on either side of the museum. I knew I’d be able to find plenty of pictures of those theaters online, mostly thanks to the bountiful website, Cinema Treasures, which maintains a large photo gallery (including some rare family snapshots sent in by its readers). My hope was that some of the vintage photos of the theaters would also include Ripley’s Wax Museum in the background.
My strategy paid off, and I found several pictures online that featured the long-gone tourist attraction, which I discovered changed its name from Ripley’s Odditorum to Ripley’s Wax Museum sometime in the late 50s or early 60s. After studying the block layout in these old photos, I realized Lumet filmed this “Pop Calls Duke” scene at nearly the same location he used for the “Picking Up Socks” scene (see below) which occurs later in the film. In fact, I noticed that the corner store with the yellow-stripe design appears in both scenes.
Italian Funeral
The church where the funeral took place was already listed on several movie websites as taking place on Sullivan Street, and it didn’t take me long to confirm it since most of the buildings are still there and look about the same.
Interestingly, none of the websites bothered to list the locations of the driving sequence that followed the funeral scene, despite the fact that they were relatively findable. I used the East River bridges to help me figure out the approximate location of the car as it drove along FDR Drive, and the only place that made sense for the toll booths was the Triborough Bridge (now called RFK).
One thing I found surprising about this sequence was its numerous continuity problems in geography. It starts with a funeral in Little Italy in downtown Manhattan, then jumps about 125 blocks north to the Triborough Bridge where the car travels east towards Queens/Long Island. Then, they’re suddenly back on Manhattan, traveling south on FDR Drive, not too far from Little Italy where this sequence began.
It’s possible this was done for visual reasons, but I have a feeling that the scene-order might’ve gotten switched around in the editing room. I say this because while the two men are driving south on the FDR, Alan King says the line, “On the way back from the funeral…” even though we’ve already seen them come out of the church funeral.
In any case, Lumet is not particularly known for being a stickler to geographical accuracy, as evidenced by his 1973 film Serpico, where he consistently substituted one borough for another.
Papa’s Mansion
Finding rural locations like this are always a lot tougher, since I can’t rely on a lot of the techniques and resources used to find NYC spots. Unless the location is identified on another movie website or available production notes, I usually have to dig through books, magazines and old newspapers in hopes that there might be a notation that will lead me to an answer.
When I consulted other movie websites, I noticed several of them indicated that the Anderson Tapes did some filming at Oheka Castle in Huntington, Long Island. At first, I thought they must be referring to this “Papa’s Mansion” scene, but after looking at some pictures of the century-old castle, I could tell that it didn’t look anything like the Tudor home that appears here. Plus the castle wasn’t near any major bodies of water, so, I dismissed it as a possibility, and was back to square one.
A breakthrough finally came when Blakeslee found an AP story from 1971 about the film, which talked about a Long Island location:
The Anderson Tapes, the suspenseful story of a $1 million robbery of a luxury apartment on New York’s Upper East Side, had its world premiere here. Sean Connery plays the leading role of an ex-confidence man who masterminds the robbery. Also in the film are Dyan Cannon, Martin Balsam and Alan King. Entire location for the Columbia film was New York, except for the portion shot at King’s waterfront home at Kings Point on Long Island.
We could only assume King’s home was used for this “Papa” scene, and our next task was to find an exact address.
At first, I thought it might be a little tricky since famous people’s addresses are usually not readily available. But to our surprise, we found a couple sources that listed King’s Long Island address, including a 1973 New York Times article reporting on his son being arrested:
Andrew King, the 18‐year‐old younger son of the comedian Alan King, was arraigned yesterday morning in Nassau County on charges of felonious possession of marijuana and hashish.
“We had him arrested,” Mr. King said yesterday while enrolling Andrew in a private, Manhattan‐based drug‐rehabilitation program where his older son, Robert, had undergone rehabilitation for heroin addiction.
The youth was arraigned in First District Court in Mineola, L.I., and released in the custody of his father. According to the police in Kings Point, L.I., Andrew was arrested at 10 P.M. Saturday near the family’s 22‐room mansion at 40 Shore Drive.
I was rather astounded that the Times would just offhandedly list a celebrity’s home address, but it ended up being a useful aid in figuring out a filming location nearly forty years later.
Sadly, King’s large Tudor residence in the private Kenilworth section of Kings Point has since been torn down. It got replaced in 2012 with an outrageously huge McMansion, whose annual property taxes alone would make your head spin. (It was reported that in 2018, the year’s taxes totaled $421,263.)
It’s a travesty that such a beautiful Great Gatsby-era mansion got replaced with an ugly, uninspired super-mansion, especially when you consider that before Alan King bought the home in 1960, it was originally built in 1926 for American lyricist, Oscar Hammerstein, of Broadway’s Rodgers and Hammerstein fame. Just goes to show that razing historically-rich buildings under the guise of “progress” isn’t just limited to NYC.
Even though I was fairly certain we found the right filming location, I still hoped to find at least one photo of the old mansion, just to ensure that we got the right place. I found the Kings Point address listed on a couple LI real estate websites, but they were all for the recently-constructed residence (which I found out is over 15,000 square feet and has 20 bathrooms). But luckily, for some reason, even though the 40 Shore Drive listing on Propertyshark.com was for the new 2012 home, the photo was of the old 1926 home.
I don’t know how that happened, but their mistake was our boon.
As a side note, having watched this film many times, I still can’t figure out what scene would’ve taken place at the aforementioned Oheka Castle. Pretty much every location from the film has been identified by Blakelsee and me, and as far as I can tell, nothing from the film came close to looking like that grandiose estate in Huntington. My guess is, someone mistakenly thought this “Papa” scene was shot at Oheka (probably because it’s been used in a lot of other film and television productions) and just absently added it to a website like IMDB. Then, just like I talked about in the Rikers Island section above, others promulgated the error.
I suppose it’s possible there was a deleted scene that was shot there, but seems unlikely.
Bathhouse
Like the church from the “Funeral” scene, this filming location for this “Bath” scene was already identified on several websites, indicating that it took place in Luxor Baths & Hotel. But unlike the church, which could simply be identified in Google Street View, an old bathhouse wasn’t as easily verifiable. That being said, I was fairly certain Luxor was correct, even before I found any pictorial evidence. From what I knew about gyms and bathhouses in the 1970s, there weren’t a huge number of other options in Manhattan that would fit the bill.
Opened in 1925, the Luxor was full-service gymnasium, hotel and bathhouse which occupied the entire 9-story building at 121 West 46th Street. The Luxor Bath and Hotel was for men only, and the clientele (referred to as habitués) included ordinary workingmen as well as the rich and famous. People like boxer Jack Dempsey, comedian Sid Caesar, author Tennessee Williams, and actor Jack Warden all passed through the lobby doors at one time. This was back in the days when famous celebrities had no qualms about sweating naked next to a plumber or an accountant.
The bath floor where this scene took place was located one level below the hotel lobby and consisted of a large swimming pool, three “hot rooms,” and several areas where you could receive a variety of services. Some of the things you could get were massages, rub-downs, cupping therapy, or a hose-down, where they sprayed you with high-pressure hoses. The concept of a private, all-male gym and bathhouse sounds a bit foreign today —like something from Ancient Rome or Turkey— but it was a perfectly normal NYC phenomena not too long ago.
Things started to change in the mid-1970s, when Luxor Baths was secretly converted into a multi-million “massage parlor” and house of prostitution — although no one seemed to know who exactly was running this illegal operation. The building owner, Seymour Durst, claimed the operators were unknown “squatters” who took over the space after the previous leasers, Astro Development Corporation, ran out of money and had to vacate the property. Luxor finally closed its doors for good around 1980 and the building was demolished and replaced in 1987.
For more details about the Luxor, check out an article by Marc Epstein, whose father used to run its day-to-day operations (before it became a multi-floor brothel).
I was already more or less willing to accept the online consensus that this bath scene was shot at the Luxor, but I was delighted when I discovered that the 1979 film, The Rose, starring Bette Midler, offered some corroborating evidence. There’s a scene in the film that shows the exterior of the bathhouse (verifying that it’s the Luxor), and then shows the interiors of the bathhouse, which matches this scene from The Anderson Tapes.
Stealing a Mayflower Truck
This was one of the first locations I identified for this movie. Seeing an elevated highway next to the parking lot made me instantly assume that it was somewhere along the west side of Manhattan, most likely between Canal and 42nd Street. After a little looking around in Google Street View, I found a parking lot near W 18th Street that looked promising. Upon closer inspection, I found several matching buildings surrounding the lot.
It might be noted that this all happened before a new skyscraper started going up on the lot in 2018, which was followed by the destruction of most of the surrounding buildings I used to identify this scene.
When I took the photo of 18th Street where the van gets loaded onto the truck, the garages on the north side of the street were still around, but have since been torn down and replaced with high-rise apartment buildings (see the photo above). Today, the only thing that remains standing from 1970 is the pier on the East River.
Antique Shop
This, too, was one of the first locations I identified from this film. There was no real work involved since I was already familiar with the neighborhood and quickly figured out that production shot this scene on 10th Street near University.
What’s cool is that the retail space that had an antique shop in it during the filming in 1970 still has an antique shop in there today — Bernd Goeckler Inc, who’ve been in business since 1989. The neighborhood actually used to be known for having a lot of secondhand shops and antique dealerships, but there’s not much left of that today.
Picking Up Socks
I figured out the location of the wide shot of the truck driving north on Sixth Avenue by looking up Galway Rose Bar, which appears in the background. After a little digging around, I found a photo of the bar, but couldn’t find an address. But the photo also showed an awning for “George Rallis Inc,” which was next door to the Galway Rose and had a building number of 805. Fortunately, there was more info online about that business, which turned out to be a long-running florist, located in the “flower district” on Sixth Avenue.
So, from there, I figured out that the truck traveled north on Sixth, going through W 28th Street, heading towards the ESB (appearing on the far right, but with its iconic spire cut off by the frame).
The second half of this sequence where Socks is picked up by the truck was fairly easy to figure out. The Howard Johnson’s restaurant was a clear-cut landmark which placed the action on 46th and Broadway in Times Square. And the former High School of Performing Arts on West 46th Street (famous for being the school that inspired the 1980 film, Fame) helped me figure out where Socks was standing.
Created in 1947, the High School offered programs in music, dance and drama. Many well-known performers were trained there, such as Eartha Kitt, Liza Minnelli, Jennifer Aniston, Ving Rhames, and Suzanne Vega. The staff included several professionals in the business, including a young Sidney Lumet, who would later feature this building in this film. (See? It’s all connected!) 
In 1984, the school was moved to Lincoln Center, where it became known as the Fiorello H. LaGuardia High School of Music & Art and Performing Arts. In 1988, the vacant Performing Arts building on 46th Street caught fire during renovation, causing much damage, but most of its stone exterior survived. After reconstructing most of the interior, the building reopened in 1995 as the Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis School of International Careers, with a plaque commemorating the former school.
Picking Up Pop
It didn’t take me too long to find the location of the wide shot of the truck traveling up an avenue. I thought it looked like the Upper East Side, so I just cruised up and down the eastern avenues in Google Street View, looking for any of the large residential buildings, figuring they were still around. About 20 minutes later, I matched up 1210 3rd Avenue on the corner of E 70th Street.
What surprised me was how much effort it took me to find the corner that Pop stood on, especially since it turned out to be on the same block as the Convent of the Sacred Heart, where the extended robbery sequence took place.
Oblivious that he was standing in front of the same building featured later in the film (where Garrett Morris’ character leans a bike against it), I instead focused on the bank across the street. Seeing that it was the First National Bank of New York, I tried to find a record of the Manhattan branch locations in old magazines and newspapers, but couldn’t find an exhaustive list online. I also tried to find a reference to the “Yankee Kitchen” on the other corner, but I couldn’t hone my online results. Then, after discovering that the First National Bank of New York later became Citibank, I started looking for current locations in Upper Manhattan (where I suspected the scene took place) and eventually came across the branch at 1275 Madison Avenue which matched the film.
So basically, the truck picked him up a half block from where the robbery took place.
The Robbery
As I mentioned earlier, most of the interiors were reportedly shot at a studio set, but a few of the interiors were shot on location, including the ornate spiral staircase and one of its balconies. According to its website, the Convent of the Sacred Heart can be rented for (undoubtedly expensive) weddings, and apparently the staircase and balcony are popular places to have photos taken. This gave me the opportunity to view some modern pictures inside of 1 W 91st Street, and confirm that they did shoot these scenes on location.
During this robbery sequence, which makes up about a third of the movie’s running time, there are several memorable cameos by a host of delightful character actors. There’s future SNL star Garrett Morris as the bicycle-riding lieutenant, future patriarchal star of TV’s Diff’rent Strokes, Conrad Bain, as an assaulted therapist, and the wicked witch from The Wizard of Oz, Margaret Hamilton, making her last big-screen appearance as one of the tenants (who may or may not be sharing her apartment with her lesbian lover).
The one thing that always bothered me with this movie was the ending, where basically everyone in the gang either gets killed or arrested. The backstory is that Columbia Pictures made Lumet change the original ending, where Connery’s character escapes the building and heads for the state line, to the current ending, where none of the thieves get away with the crime. The movie studio supposedly insisted these changes be made in anticipation of eventually selling the film to network television which had a stricter “crime doesn’t pay” moral code.
I always thought this explanation sounded a bit far-fetched but I suppose it could be true. I just can’t imagine Lumet would change the ending just to satisfy some potential future TV censors. If push came to shove, I would think that he’d simply film an alternative ending for television. I definitely would have liked to have seen Duke Anderson escape the police, or at the very least, not see so many of his fellow thieves die in the process. 
That being said, I do actually like the very ending of the film where all the government agencies realize that their surveillance programs have all inadvertently (and illegally) recorded Anderson, but they were still unable to prevent a major robbery from taking place. The last few seconds of the movie then shows all the “Anderson tapes” being erased from existence.
Despite some of its shortcomings, this little, often overlooked heist film is a fine addition to Lumet’s body of work. And it did end up being somewhat prescient, as it was completed mere months before a secret sound recording system was installed in the Oval Office, which would eventually lead to President Nixon’s resignation.
And today, who knows how often our voice is recorded or our picture is taken on daily basis? 
With Connery’s passing, I hope people will remember this inimitable Scottish actor for his many other roles besides James Bond, including the titular character from this film, Duke Anderson.
