The Wrong Man (1956) [UPDATE]

Generally speaking, I try not to publish a post about a movie until I think I’ve found every possible filming location for it. But every once in a while, a new discovery pops up afterwards, and I am pleased that one has popped up for “The Wrong Man.”

I’m putting this new location in this quick update post, but I’ve also added it to my main post on the film so there’s proper context as to where the location shows up in the storyline.

 

Looking For a Witness on the Waterfront

ezgif.com-gif-maker
Manny and Rose continue their search for one of the witnesses from the vacation house, going inside 104 22nd Street in Brooklyn, only to discover that the man they’re looking for is dead.

 


This was obviously shot in some waterfront area in NYC, but the question was — where? The one big clue was the ship in the background. My hope was to figure out the name of the vessel, then figure out if it regularly moored at a particular pier.

Unable to read what the name said on the side of the ship, I enlisted Blakeslee’s help, as he is quite deft at deciphering blurry or incomplete words. After a little studying of a zoomed-in frame from the film, he concluded it was the SS Kathryn (originally a military cargo ship, called the USS Duplin). After a little digging around, we discovered that that ship’s regular port was at the “Brooklyn Piers,” in particular, Pier C, which was in the Gowanus Bay area.

wrong-pier 704 3 Avenue 1940tax

From there, it was off to the New York City Municipal Archives in search of any tax photos from the area. Figuring Fonda and Miles entered a multi-story building, it didn’t take too much searching before we focused in on 704 3rd Avenue on the corner of 22nd Street. Next to that building were a series of stables/garages which clearly matched what was seen in the film.

wrong-pier garage compare2
A still from the 1956 film (left) compared to a ca 1940 tax photo of 104-106 22 Street (right) with matching garage/stable doors.

 

What’s interesting is that I originally thought this scene took place in Manhattan near the South Street Seaport, mainly because I thought I saw either the Brooklyn of Manhattan Bridge in the background (appearing between the ship and the building they go into). Turns out it was just some generic derricks or whatnot off the pier.

Sadly, most of the buildings from the scene are long gone, but the building at 40 22nd Street is still standing. (It’s pretty much the last building on the block with a pointy top.) Also, as far as I can tell, the large hanger-like buildings on 21st Street (which are partially visible on the right side of the frame at the top of this scene) have also survived.

wrong-pier 40 22nd compare2
A still from the film as well as a screen shot from Google Street View, with a red arrow indicating the extant building at 40 22nd Street.

 

USS_Duplin_(AKA-87)_at_anchor,_circa_in_1945_(NH_78560)

As to the ship, after serving in World War II, the large cargo vessel was decommissioned by the Navy in 1946 and sold into merchant service, where its name was changed from USS Duplin to SS Kathryn. It then spent several years working out of the piers seen in this film. After being bought and sold several times throughout the 1960s (as well as being renamed at least two more times), the ship was finally scrapped in January of 1971.

One thought on “The Wrong Man (1956) [UPDATE]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s